Two days after Sam’s arrest, Arthur Vance scheduled an emergency deposition at his office.
Because of Sam’s felony charges, Robert had been forced to retain an outside criminal defense attorney for his youngest son. But Robert himself—arrogant, immaculately groomed in a bespoke three-piece wool suit—insisted on attending the probate deposition as the lead counsel for John and Liz.
When I entered the conference room with Arthur, the atmosphere was poisonous.
Uncle Robert sat at the far end of the long glass table, flanked by John and Liz. John looked haggard, his eyes darting anxiously around the room; the arrogance from the diner was replaced by a tense, twitchy hostility. Liz had spent the morning applying heavy makeup to conceal the dark circles under her eyes, her arms crossed defensively across her chest.
Robert didn't even look at me. He looked at Arthur Vance with thinly veiled contempt.
“Arthur,” Robert drawled, adjusting his gold cufflinks. “I assume you called this deposition to discuss settlement terms before this unfortunate situation with my boy Samuel spirals any further. We’re willing to drop the undue influence petition in exchange for a fifty-fifty split of the property portfolio. That’s more than generous considering the circumstances.”
Arthur took his seat, unfolded a clean yellow legal pad, and uncapped his fountain pen.
“We aren't here to discuss a settlement, Robert,” Arthur said mildly. “We are here to depose your clients regarding their claims of testamentary incapacity and their allegations of elder exploitation against Mark.”
Robert let out a sharp, mocking laugh. “Don't waste our time, Arthur. Mark has no leverage. He’s an unemployed web developer facing public ruin. The smear campaign has already cost him his primary business accounts. We can keep this estate frozen in probate for three years. Can Mark afford three years of property maintenance out of pocket?”
“Actually, Uncle Robert,” I spoke up, leaning forward with my hands flat on the table, “I’m not the one running out of time.”
John slammed his fist on the table. “Shut up, Mark! You don't speak! You’re nothing but a paid attendant who stole our birthright! You had my brother thrown in jail!”
“Your brother broke into an occupied apartment building with a pipe wrench and industrial solvent, John,” Arthur Vance said sharply, his voice slicing through the room like a razor. “He is facing five to ten years in state prison. The security footage is conclusive, and the District Attorney has already declined bail reduction.”
Liz’s eyes welled with angry tears. “Sam made a mistake because you drove him to desperation! You’re an evil person, Mark!”
“Let’s talk about desperation,” Arthur said smoothly.
He reached into his leather briefcase and pulled out three bound copies of the Mayo Clinic medical dossier, sliding one across the table to Robert.
Robert glanced at the cover page, and for the first time, his smug expression cracked. His eyes flickered rapidly across Dr. Chen’s evaluation.
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
“A comprehensive, video-recorded cognitive evaluation conducted four months prior to Clara’s passing,” Arthur explained. “Her mental capacity is established as absolute. Your petition for undue influence is dead on arrival. In fact, if you proceed with that motion on Monday, I will personally file for Rule 11 sanctions against you and your firm for filing a frivolous claim with known falsified affidavits.”
Robert shoved the dossier aside, his jaw working furiously. “A doctor's opinion is subject to cross-examination! We still have evidence of isolation! He prevented her family from visiting!”
“Did he?” Arthur asked.
Arthur reached into the briefcase again and placed a portable cassette player on the table.
Robert froze. His face went entirely pale, the color draining from his cheeks so rapidly he looked like an open corpse.
“I believe you recognize this recording, Robert,” Arthur said quietly.
Arthur pressed play.
Robert’s own voice rang out in the quiet conference room: *“I don't have six hundred grand lying around... What do you need the money for anyway? Nursing homes accept Medicaid once your assets are depleted... Don't bother calling my kids for help. They have careers. They don't have time to change diapers for a bitter old woman.”*
John turned his head toward his father, his eyes wide with utter confusion. “Dad... what is that? What is he talking about? Six hundred grand?”
Liz stared at her father, her mouth hanging open. “Dad? What was that?”
Robert didn't answer. He was staring at the small black cassette player as if it were a ticking bomb.
“In addition to this recording,” Arthur continued, his voice dropping into a lethal, measured cadence, “we have recovered the signed confession of judgment from August 2014, wherein you, Robert Davis, admitted to embezzling six hundred thousand dollars from the estate of Margaret Holloway, which Clara paid on your behalf to save you from federal indictment.”
Arthur slid a second document across the table.
“With interest compounded over ten years, the current balance due to Clara’s estate is one million, one hundred and forty-two thousand dollars.”
John jumped out of his chair. “What is this?! Dad, tell them they’re lying! Tell them this is fake!”
“Sit down, John!” Robert croaked, his voice entirely devoid of its earlier bravado. He looked like an old, broken man who had suddenly seen the gallows being erected outside his window.
“If this estate goes to full probate trial,” Arthur said, leaning across the glass table, “this entire file—the confession of embezzlement, the cashier’s check trail, and this audio recording—will be entered into the public record. Within twenty-four hours, the state bar will strip your license, the federal prosecutor will reopen the Holloway fraud investigation, and every single dime you and your children possess will be seized to satisfy the estate's judgment.”
The room went dead silent.
May you like
001 My Husband Crashed Our Son’s Wedding Wearing My Vintage Gown—When He...
30/10B7 My Father Gave My Graduation VIP Pass To My Stepsister And Pushe...
30/10B37 My Family Invited My Cheating Wife To Thanksgiving And Told Me...
The only sound was the faint hum of the air conditioner and the ragged, shallow breathing of Uncle Robert.
***